PR Newswire
BALTIMORE, Oct. 9, 2024
Proposal Would Deliver Immediate and Certain 14.5% Premium to Whitestone Shareholders Compared to Share Price Prior to Initial Proposal
Per Share Price Represents a 61.8% Premium to Whitestone's Unaffected Share Price Prior to Takeover Rumors
Sends Letter to Whitestone Board Detailing Compelling and Certain Value of All-Cash Proposal
Launches www.MaximizingWhitestoneValue.com
BALTIMORE, Oct. 9, 2024 /PRNewswire/ -- MCB Real Estate ("MCB"), a leading commercial real estate developer and investment management firm with a diverse nationwide portfolio and approximately $3 billion in AUM, today sent a letter to the Board of Trustees of Whitestone REIT (NYSE: WSR) ("Whitestone") increasing the value of its proposal to acquire the company in an all-cash transaction. Additional materials regarding the proposal are available at www.MaximizingWhitestoneValue.com.
Under the terms of the revised proposal, Whitestone shareholders would receive $15.00 per share in cash, representing a 14.5% premium to Whitestone's share price as of June 3, 2024, the last trading day prior to the disclosure of MCB's previous proposal, a 11.4% premium to Whitestone's last trading share price, and a 61.8% premium to the Whitestone share price prior to the rumored Fortress proposal in October 2023. MCB's proposal is not subject to any financing contingency.
"As the third largest Whitestone shareholder and largest actively managed shareholder, our interests are aligned with the company's other owners and we are committed to pursuing a transaction that maximizes value," said MCB Managing Partner and Co-Founder P. David Bramble. "Our efforts to engage in constructive discussions have been rebuffed to date, but we stand ready to complete due diligence and execute a definitive agreement expeditiously and are committed to seeing this through to completion. We ask our fellow shareholders to urge the Whitestone Board to uphold their fiduciary duties and engage with us in good faith without further delay."
MCB previously disclosed a proposal to acquire Whitestone for $14.00 per share in cash on June 3, 2024. Since then, Whitestone stock has notably underperformed its Peers1 and is still trading at approximately the same value as when MCB submitted its previous proposal.
MCB sent the following letter to the Whitestone Board regarding the revised proposal:
October 9, 2024
Board of Trustees
C/O David K. Holeman
Whitestone REIT
2600 S. Gessner Rd, Suite 500
Houston, TX 77063
Dear Whitestone REIT Board of Trustees:
As a follow-up to our conversations following the MCB Real Estate ("MCB" or "we") offer to acquire Whitestone REIT ("Whitestone" or the "Company"), submitted on June 3, 2024, and based on feedback we received from Whitestone shareholders, MCB is hereby increasing its offer to acquire all of the outstanding common shares of Whitestone, including all of the outstanding common partnership interests ("OP Units") in Whitestone REIT Operating Partnership, L.P. (the "OP"), to a price of $15.00 per share (the "Revised Proposal").
The improved $15.00 per share all-cash proposal provides compelling and certain value to Whitestone shareholders, representing a 14.5% premium to Whitestone's share price as of June 3, 2024, the last trading day prior to the disclosure of our previous proposal, and a 11.4% premium to Whitestone's last trading share price. In addition, relative to the Whitestone share price prior to the rumored Fortress offer, our $15.00 per share proposal represents a 61.8% premium. Whitestone has not closed above $15.00 per share since 2016. As the third largest Whitestone shareholder and largest actively managed shareholder, with 4,690,000 shares representing 9.4% of Whitestone's common shares, our interests are aligned with other shareholders. We are focused on maximizing shareholder value and are confident that this proposal is the most compelling opportunity to achieve that goal.
Over the past few months since the initial proposal was disclosed on June 3, 2024, Whitestone's stock has noticeably underperformed its Peers1, still trading at approximately the same level as when MCB submitted the previous proposal.
- Whitestone's share price has increased 2.8% since our initial proposal was disclosed on June 3, 2024, while Peer share prices have risen 17.7% (see Figure 1).
- Whitestone's share price has decreased 2.4% since the report of its second quarter 2024 earnings results, while Peer share prices have increased 4.0%.
- Whitestone's current 12.8x consensus NTM FFO multiple is 2.3 multiple turns lower than the Peers. This multiple discount is consistent with historical averages and has expanded significantly from the 0.4 multiple turns discount at the time of the previous proposal. The trading discount is reflective of Whitestone's small capitalization and trading float, limited growth prospects and weaker overall asset quality relative to the Peer group.
(See figure 1)
Whitestone is burdened with a cost of capital disadvantage relative to its public and private peers. MCB believes that the Company is trading at a cap rate, based on last twelve months NOI of approximately $102 million, of 7.7%. The Company's cost of borrowing, based on its corporate credit facility, is SOFR+1.70%, which equates to a borrowing rate above 6.5% with today's SOFR rate. In addition, to preserve capital for growth initiatives, the Company cut its dividend in April 2020 and has a lower dividend yield than the majority of Peers, which will also continue to limit future share price appreciation due to the lack of support from retail and income-oriented investors. The expensive cost of equity and cost of borrowing make it a challenge for Whitestone to raise any new capital to fund acquisitions, developments or redevelopments, or tenant buyouts and asset repositioning. These are the fundamental drivers of value creation for shareholders and illustrate why the Company should not remain public.
Since making our initial proposal, we've heard from a number of shareholders that they are supportive of a potential transaction and would like to see the Whitestone Board engage with us. During that time, we have attempted on numerous occasions to engage with the Whitestone management team to work toward a transaction that would maximize value for Whitestone shareholders. We are now delivering a per share proposal price that is higher than where Whitestone shares have closed at any point in over eight years.
While our efforts have been rebuffed to date, we remain committed to seeing our proposed transaction through to completion as we strongly believe this is the right path forward for shareholders. We are confident that with engagement and diligence, we can quickly reach agreement on a transaction that delivers far more value for Whitestone shareholders than they could achieve if Whitestone stays on its current course.
We expect to fund the acquisition with a combination of equity and debt. Our contemplated equity for this transaction is fully committed from discretionary capital managed by MCB. With respect to the debt portion of the acquisition, we have received a Highly Confident Letter from Wells Fargo with respect to the debt financing needed to complete the transaction, to be converted to a full commitment at execution of the definitive transaction agreements. The Highly Confident Letter was attached to the original proposal and has been reaffirmed by Wells Fargo. Any definitive transaction agreement between us and the Company would not be subject to a financing contingency. Representatives of Wells Fargo are available to address any questions you may have on the proposed debt financing.
MCB is a trusted leader in commercial real estate investment with a track record of high-performance investments throughout the United States. We have considerable resources and access to capital, and a consistent track record of successfully closing complex commercial real estate transactions. Based on our knowledge of the industry and public data regarding your portfolio and financial performance, we are confident our improved $15.00 per share offer represents an extremely compelling proposal.
We have reviewed in detail this potential transaction with our Investment Committee and have received full support to submit this proposal. Any binding offer for the Company on behalf of MCB would require the final approval of our Investment Committee. No binding obligation or commitment for either of us will arise with respect to this Revised Proposal or any transaction until we have executed a mutually agreeable definitive agreement.
We remain very enthusiastic about an acquisition of Whitestone and will immediately commit the resources to expeditiously move forward. Please do not hesitate to call me if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
/s/ P. David Bramble
P. David Bramble, Managing Partner
cc:
Via email, under separate cover:
Peter Pinkard, Managing Partner
Gina Baker Chambers, President
Drew Gorman, Principal
Mike Trail, Chief Investment Officer
Brian Mendell, Managing Director
Daniel LeBey, Vinson & Elkins L.L.P.
1 Peers defined as AKR, BRX, FRT, IVT, KIM, KRG, PECO, REG, ROIC, UE.
Advisors
MCB has engaged Vinson & Elkins LLP as lead counsel in connection with the transaction. Wells Fargo is serving as financial advisor to MCB.
About MCB Real Estate
Founded in 2007, MCB Real Estate is a community-centric, privately held institutional investment management firm headquartered in Baltimore, Maryland. MCB boasts a nationwide portfolio of $3 Billion Assets Under Management totaling approximately 15 million square-feet. of industrial, office, retail, mixed-use, multi-family and life sciences properties with almost four million square-feet in its development pipeline. The firm offers a seamlessly integrated suite of commercial real estate investment services, including development, construction, property management, asset management, acquisitions, and legal expertise, thus ensuring comprehensive support throughout every stage of an asset's lifecycle. www.mcbrealestate.com.
Media Contacts
Andrew Siegel / Lucas Pers / Lyle Weston
Joele Frank, Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher
212-355-4449
View original content to download multimedia:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/mcb-real-estate-increases-proposal-to-acquire-whitestone-reit-to-15-00-per-share-in-cash-and-seeks-board-engagement-302271549.html
SOURCE MCB Real Estate
