A Closer Look at UPS's Agreement With Teamsters

A win-win-win for all?

Author's Avatar
Aug 15, 2023
Summary
  • Agreement between UPS and Teamsters is being hailed as a win-win-win for customers, employees and the company.
  • By the end of the contract, the average UPS full-time driver will make approximately $170,000 annually in pay and benefits.
  • UPS being the industry leader in labor costs isn't a good thing.
Article's Main Image

In a recent announcement, United Parcel Service Inc. (UPS, Financial) CEO Carol Tomé shared the company's successful agreement with the Teamsters Union, highlighting the benefits for all parties involved. This agreement marks a significant milestone for UPS and its employees, solidifying its position as a leading logistics provider. Let's delve into the details of this agreement and its implications for UPS, its customers and the union.

Understanding the agreement

The agreement between UPS and the Teamsters Union is being hailed as a win-win-win. It addresses the concerns and priorities of the Teamsters' leadership, UPS employees and the company itself. The contract ensures that UPS continues to reward its employees with competitive pay and benefits, solidifying its position as an industry leader in this regard.

Key changes in the new contract

The new contract brings several positive changes for UPS employees. One significant change is the conversion of all 22.4 employees, who are weekend delivery drivers, to regular full-time packaged car drivers. This provides UPS with the flexibility to schedule delivery drivers from Tuesday through Saturday, while also offering improved work-life balance for the drivers.

Working conditions for all UPS employees will also see improvements, including the introduction of air conditioning in every new U.S. packaged car starting in January 2024. The contract also allows UPS to introduce new technology and utilize seasonal support during peak holiday seasons.

Furthermore, the contract strengthens the industry-leading pay and benefits that Teamster employees already enjoy. By the end of the contract, the average UPS full-time driver will make approximately $170,000 annually in pay and benefits. Part-time union employees will also see an increase in their minimum hourly wage to $25.75, along with full health care and pension benefits.

Implications for shareholders

Tomé delved into the second-quarter results, acknowledging the negotiations with the Teamsters had a significant impact on volume diversion. Consolidated revenue for the quarter declined by 10.9% to $22.1 billion due to lower volume. However, UPS managed to deliver $2.9 billion of operating profit, in line with expectations. The consolidated operating margin exceeded expectations at 13.2%.

1691564395093557248.png

Tomé also discussed UPS's progress in becoming the number one complex health care logistics provider globally. The company opened its first dedicated health care distribution facility in Ireland, expanding its European footprint. Revenue from the health care portfolio reached $4.7 billion in the first six months of 2023, with an expected full-year revenue of $10 billion.

International expansion and technological innovations

On the international front, UPS has been rapidly expanding in India, one of the fastest-growing economies in the world. The company launched MOVIN, an asset-light domestic joint venture, and expanded its coverage to 49 of the largest cities in India, representing approximately 90% of the business-to-business market opportunity.

Tomé concluded her remarks by emphasizing UPS's innovation-driven approach. The company leverages technology, such as the network planning tools, which use artificial intelligence and machine learning to quickly make changes to planning, scheduling and volume flows across the network. NPT enabled UPS to match capacity with volume levels, resulting in a nearly 10% reduction in hours in the U.S. while maintaining industry-leading service. The company is also making progress in rolling out its RFID initiative, Smart Package Smart Facility, with almost 50% of U.S. buildings operating with this technology by the end of the second quarter.

FedEx's position amid UPS's negotiations

FedEx Corp. (FDX, Financial) has been benefiting from the recent Teamster negotiations with UPS. According to Brie Carere, an executive at FedEx, the company has not seen any material benefit from the UPS labor negotiations in the fourth quarter of 2023. However, she mentioned these negotiations have opened up a lot of doors for FedEx and they are having great conversations with legacy UPS customers. This indicates the company is capitalizing on the opportunity to attract customers who may be looking for alternatives due to the negotiations.

Over 500 UPS executives had regular contact with customers to prevent volume diversion or win back diverted volume after the settlement. Tomé emphasized the company's commitment to executing win-back initiatives and leveraging investments in the digital customer experience to tap into the $7 billion sales pipeline opportunity.

Competitive advantage and market opportunities

Carere also expressed confidence in FedEx's strong value proposition compared to its primary competitor, UPS. This suggests that FedEx is positioning itself as a favorable option for customers who may be seeking reliable and efficient shipping services. The company's sales pipeline is expected to benefit from these conversations and the perceived advantages over UPS.

1691564413561077760.png

Furthermore, Carere mentioned FedEx has seen a shift in customer trades within its portfolio, particularly in the Asia region. With the reopening of the International Economy product in the fourth quarter, FedEx has experienced positive performance and is pleased with the sales pipeline in the Asia-Pacific team. This indicates it is successfully attracting customers who may have previously relied on UPS for their shipping needs.

Overall, while FedEx did not see immediate material benefits from the UPS labor negotiations, the company is optimistic about the long-term opportunities that have arisen as a result. By leveraging its strong value proposition and engaging in conversations with legacy UPS customers, FedEx is well-positioned to benefit from the changing dynamics in the shipping industry.

Analysts' perspective on UPS's situation

While Tomé was exceptionally skillful in delivering an upbeat message, the analysts in the room did not buy it. The response has been overwhelmingly negative. All analysts reporting to Zacks.com downgraded the stock for this quarter, this year and next year. After all, a $170,000 pay and benefits package has me rethinking what I do for a living. Lots of pay equals lots of cost and when FedEx is not yet ruled by the Teamsters, it seems like the company can use this as an opportunity to gain market share though lower-cost services.